The Independent London Newspaper
21st May 2012

Letters

‘We are all going to die. Who doesn’t want a say in it?’

In a unique interview, Katherine Lennard explains why she has signed up for assisted suicide at a Swiss centre – and why it has brought a sense of relief

Published: January 19, 2012
EXCLUSIVE by TOM FOOT

WHEN the time comes she will book a one-way air ticket knowing her final glimpse of London will be the city disappearing behind her as she sets off for Zurich.

Katherine Lennard has signed up for assisted suicide at the Dignitas centre in Switzerland.

The 55-year-old – a former primary school teacher and head of special needs in Camden – was diagnosed with a rare form of cancer two years ago.

In an interview explaining why she is among the handful of Britons who apply to Dignitas every year, Ms Lennard explains today how laws criminalising assisted suicide in this country mean she is facing up to the reality of spending her last days abroad.

She says she must make the trip while she is still well enough to get there.

At her home in Belsize Park, Ms Lennard spoke frankly and philosophically about the “loneliness” of terminal illness, the “taboo” surrounding death in this country and her firm, personal belief that, despite the often divisive debate around assisted suicide and Dignitas, what she is doing is right.

She talked of the absurd cruelty of legislation that prevents her from dying when and where she wants to, peacefully, without endangering her family with prosecution, and in her own home.

“At the beginning I was in a deep, dark manhole,” she said. “With the help of a friend, I climbed out, very slowly. I began to come to terms with and accept my future, whatever path it would take. After I signed up [to Dignitas], there was a sense of relief. I could see more clearly. I dared to climb up the wall, and look over it. I looked at death very hard. Nobody looks at death until they have to climb up that wall. It was silence on the other side, but I had to give it a voice.”

She added: “We are all going to die – hands up who doesn’t want a say in it? The arguments against it are pretty thin.”

At Dignitas, experts administer a lethal overdose of a barbiturate in a glass of water or fruit juice to induce a peaceful and painless death.

In her kitchen on Tuesday night, her son, Tommy, was having a bite to eat before meeting his father to watch Queens Park Rangers play.

The 17-year-old does not agree with his mother’s decision to go to Dignitas, a view he wants on the record. “I don’t think it’s right to end your own life – it feels like giving in. But I do accept that people should have the choice,” he said.

Ms Lennard said:  “I’m glad we are having a dialogue about this.”

She saw her father die from a similar condition seven years ago. It was a death, following seven weeks in hospital, that she does not wish for herself.

“My father’s time had come,” she said. “He needed to die. But the emphasis was always about keeping him alive. I don’t see why it should be like that. I think people are afraid of what they do not know. They do not want to talk about what happens after death or the process of dying.”

Ms Lennard added: “My death is not imminent, but I am forced now to look at how I might die due to our inadequate laws.”

In 2009, Ms Lennard was referred by her local GP to St John’s and Elizabeth Hospital in St John’s Wood, where she was told she had five tumours in her liver.

They were neuroendocrine tumours, a slow-growing form of cancer, known as NETs, which had spread from her lungs.

She said: “It was said of Steve Jobs [co-founder of Apple] that he had pancreatic cancer, but in fact he had NETs. He could have done more to publicise the profile of the condition. It is a very, very rare form of cancer and I have a very rare form of that cancer.”

The Royal Free Hospital in Hampstead, where she is being treated, has a NETs unit with an international reputation. In 2010, it was the first UK centre to be awarded a prestigious European Centre of Excellence award. Ms Lennard said she had been “incredibly lucky” to be seen there and was planning to fundraise for the NHS hospital in Pond Street throughout the year.

Life-saving operations have seen half of her liver and half a lung removed. The tumours were stabilised but Ms Lennard said she does not know how long she will live – she hopes and expects there could be many years to come.

But the certainty that she will not suffer a painful death has become a great comfort, she said.

“If you are in my position you are forced to look at your own mortality,” Ms Lennard said.

“I’m a woman who runs a family, and was head of special needs at a school. I like being in control. If I knew now that there was someone who could come with the medicine in my house when I knew it was the right time, I promise you there is a part of me that would be so much more peaceful. But that is not the case  because of the law as it stands at the moment.”

Although having a strong and close-knit family around her, and many friends, Ms Lennard described her position as “lonely”, adding: “You want to talk about dying, and death. But you can’t. Most people want to talk positively, they want to make it better.”

Lord Falconer, funded by the author Sir Terry Pratchett, who has Alzheimer’s disease, has headed a review of the law into assisted dying.

The Commission on Assisted Dying final report, published earlier this month, recommended that Parliament consider new safeguarding frameworks to permit terminally ill people – those who have a progressive, incurable condition – to end their life with a doctor’s assistance. The report found that already 0.2 per cent of deaths attended by doctors constitute voluntary euthanasia.

Often, it is the palliative care team who administer a soothing injection when all hope is lost. Ms Lennard said: “This is the way it used to be in this country, but mainly because of reaction in the US, doctors do not dare.”

Opponents of legal assisted suicide argue that some might consider it because they are worried their care needs are some form of burden to relatives.

Ms Lennard has studied the confusing  laws surrounding assisted suicide. “One of the things that keeps striking me, my husband is a lawyer and we had a conversation about it last night, is that assisted suicide remains a criminal offence in England,” she said.

“You can get up to 14 years. The guidance says those helping ‘loved ones’ to die should not be prosecuted. On the one hand you can get 14 years, but if you can prove you loved the person you don’t. Well what a fudge that is. It’s vague.”

Her sons are aged 20 and 17 and her husband 59. “I don’t see why my relatives should be involved in it, in the practical act of my death,” she said. “It would be a dirty, messy business. If you have to go to Switzerland, the horror of it is really inconceivable. To say goodbye to your children – they will never see you again – or should they come out with me? Why not do this in my own bedroom?”

Ms Lennard speaks of plans for the rest of her life optimistically and her campaign for a better understanding
of NETs.

She has started painting – “plagiarising” great works by artists like Matisse – and wants to write, read and travel to new places. “Not only to discover new things,” she said, “but also to enjoy new places.”

• Ms Lennard would like to know what the wider public thinks about assisted suicide and has suggested the New Journal asks readers’ opinions.

The Dignitas way – 700 sign up in this country

DIGNITAS, a not-for-profit organisation based near Zurich, aims to ensure members “live and die with dignity” in accordance with Swiss law.

Members ready to die write explaining their reasons. A doctor decides whether, based on  medical history, a fatal dose can be administered.

There are then two appointments – to check records and prescribe drugs – before two Dignitas staff members organise and witness the death. Cost is typically around £4,000, but those who cannot afford the fees may pay less.

There are currently 694 members of Dignitas living in the UK.

Comments

You have the right to die

I am a medical doctor and the truth is - we do assist you to die. Because that is the merciful thing to do. I hope that when my time comes I have a choice. We are all going to die - medicine can help you live longer (sometimes); it may even help you to prevent certain types of deaths e.g. lung cancer vs heart attack. I don't believe I fear death - I fear the pain and suffering of a slow and drawn out inevitable end. Doctors are more likely than any other profession to have advance directives indicating they do not want to be resuscitated. Less than 10% of patients who undergo CPR and survive live for more than a month. The difficulty in life is not knowing when to fight - it's knowing when to quit. This courageous woman has taken the burden to turn off ventilators and watch her painful decline into non-being away from her children. This is nothing other than an act of tremendous courage and love.

Assisted Dying

There are so many question marks attached to this topic. Obviously Katherine's son does not want his mother to end her life. But, when the time comes (hopefully many, many years from now) would he want to watch his mother suffer if she has lost all quality of life? I think not. Even the definition of 'quality of life' is up to the individual. People can tolerate pain at different levels - both emotional pain and physical pain. Surely it is up to the individual to know when
he or she can take no more. This is such a complex and emotionally-driven issue that will take time and care to sort out in the law. But it seems right for an individual to be able to choose their time to depart this earth when they are terminally ill - and why not allow them the last pleasure of being surrounded by the people they love in their home country. We don't let our animals endure slow, painful deaths - why can't we help each other pass away with dignity and peace?

Dying without looking at the alternatives??

I have yet to read anyone encouraging this woman ( sorry if this is you, Katherine, reading this) but I have yet to read anyone encouraging this woman, the alternative way, diet, supplements and so on..

I have 2 cancers and I am not giving up on myself just yet, nor am I putting myself down for assisted suicide..

Get in touch if you need some help.. or want it... Kind regards..

Brave Lady

I think you speak of your circumstances with courage and conviction and I think that it is commendable speaking out on a taboo subject such as death.
It reminds me of a saying I recently heard "it's easy to die but not easy to kill yourself" what I mean by that is you have many people who spend years abusing their bodies through drink and or drugs and are ok physically and then on the other hand you have people who don't and face incurable illnesses.
I battled alcoholism for many years until becoming sober in 2010,i feel somewhat guilty for coming out of it particularly unscathed but it is what it is i guess.
I had to write not just to write about myself but remembering when I worked with you i have horrible memories of not doing my job to the best of my ability because of my particular illness being alcoholism.
I have many ghosts to clear out of my closet and that being one of them i am a good person but not seeking help sooner let myself and others down.
I have now found the help I needed and I wish you all the best!
Your story has really touched my heart and I thank you being open and honest about how you feel may it bring courage and hope to many others!
naomi

morally wrong?

What moral code does Anonymous have in mind to say that assisted suicide is morally wrong? What right does Anonymous have to make a moral judgement on me?

If Anonymous does have such a code and thinks I would be acting against it when I killed myself with aid from another person, then I hope Anonymous can tolerate that.

I do not want to offend Anonymous, but suicide is not illegal. I consider that my body is my responsibility, and that my life is my responsibility.

I want to die at my own hand and at my own time, with help if I need it. And I want that help to be legal. Please, Anonymous, be more tolerant.

Peter Bruggen NW3

Hope the law is changed

Well done for pinpointing the problem with our law and publicising it. Whilst I don't think I would choose Dignitas myself I do believe we should have the choice to die with the full support (whatever form that may take) of our loved ones and, at home, or at the very least, still in our own country.

Hope the law is changed

Well done for pinpointing the problem with our law and publicising it. Whilst I don't think I would choose Dignitas myself I do believe we should have the choice to die with the full support (whatever form that may take) of our loved ones and, at home, or at the very least, still in our own country.

WOW

I must commend your courage to write publicly. You evidently have strong opinions about the subject, however, I tend to agree with your son. He pinpoints the key problem that assisted suicide is morally wrong but it is not for one to tell another what or what not to do!

Assisted dying

Thank you anonymous.....Just to clarify what I think you mean..... suicide may be wrong by your own moral standard...so you would chose to die a natural death. If, as you say, you believe it is not for one to tell another what to do,then your moral position would not effect your vote which would be in favourite of assisted dying.

Post new comment